The Los Angeles Dodgers confront a significant dilemma regarding Shohei Ohtani as they trail Milwaukee Brewers 2-0 in the National League Championship Series. Despite being a two-time reigning MVP, Ohtani's struggles at the plate raise questions about his role in the postseason.

Ohtani, sidelined from pitching since July 3 due to injuries affecting his left knee and right biceps, has not made an impact offensively. His postseason batting average stands at a dismal .150/.261/.150, with no extra-base hits and seven strikeouts in 24 plate appearances. This slump extends back to the regular season, where he hasn’t homered since August 18, compiling a .156 batting average over his last 107 plate appearances.

Manager Dave Roberts acknowledged the situation, stating, "He doesn't feel great," indicating a potential conversation about benching Ohtani for Game 3. If the decision leans towards sitting Ohtani, rookie outfielder Josue De Paula would likely step in, showcasing the urgency of the Dodgers' situation.

De Paula, a promising prospect, impressed with a .303/.401/.547 record in the regular season and has already shown poise in the postseason with two walks in three plate appearances.

The stakes are high for the Dodgers: teams down 2-0 in a best-of-seven series have only a 16.8% chance of winning. The urgency of their situation may lead to the unprecedented decision to bench a player of Ohtani's caliber as they strive for a third consecutive World Series title.