A shocking decision during the World Cup 2026 match between France and Senegal left referees and pundits alike bewildered. In the 58th minute, Kylian Mbappe was challenged by Sadio Mane inside the penalty area while the game remained goalless at the New York New Jersey Stadium. Referee Alireza Faghani was called to the pitchside monitor to review the incident.

Upon returning, Faghani appeared to indicate a penalty to the delight of the French supporters. However, the joy was fleeting as he later clarified that he had actually signaled for a goal-kick, stating that Mbappe had initiated the contact.

This decision sparked outrage among former referees and players:

• Darren Cann, assistant referee for the 2010 World Cup final, reported receiving numerous messages from top referees who were equally baffled by the lack of a penalty.
• Pat Nevin, former Scotland winger, criticized the call as "rubbish," expressing disbelief that Mbappe could be responsible for initiating contact.
• Alan Shearer, former England captain, echoed this sentiment, calling the decision "bizarre" and questioning how Mbappe could have initiated contact when he was in front of Mane.

The incident highlights the ongoing debates surrounding VAR decisions and their impact on the game, particularly in high-stakes tournaments like the World Cup.