As Alexander Zverev stood at the microphone after his quarter-final win over Rafael Jodar, a violent hailstorm disrupted his victory lap on Court Philippe-Chatrier. This biblical downpour felt symbolic, drawing attention to Zverev's controversial presence in tennis.

Two realities coexist: Zverev, a three-time Grand Slam finalist, is the favorite for the Coupe des Mousquetaires, yet his history raises discomfort among fans and observers. In October 2023, he faced a penalty order for bodily harm against his former girlfriend, Brenda Patea, leading to a fine of almost £400,000. Despite the serious allegations, Zverev continued playing while the ATP drew criticism for his appointment to the Players Advisory Council in January 2024.

In June 2024, during the French Open, Zverev reached an out-of-court settlement with Patea, which allowed him to avoid a trial. He has denied all allegations, labeling them as “bullshit.” Prior accusations of domestic abuse from another ex-girlfriend, Olga Sharypova, were also dismissed by the ATP due to insufficient evidence. However, the ATP's failure to enact its own regulations regarding suspensions for players under legal scrutiny has sparked further criticism.

Despite Zverev's talent, his journey to the title remains marred by ethical questions. Having spent less than 12 hours on court to reach the last four, he is positioned as a clear favorite against an inexperienced opponent. Yet, social media buzzes with the phrase “anyone but Zverev,” reflecting a resigned attitude among fans.

Zverev's history of collapsing in crucial moments adds to the tension surrounding his potential victory. Should he win, the questions about his ethical standing and the ATP's policies will persist, marking this Roland-Garros title with an asterisk in the minds of many. This tournament may well be one that observers wish to forget.