Germany's exit from the World Cup marks a painful new chapter in their footballing history. For the first time in 44 years, a German player missed a penalty in a World Cup shootout, as Kai Havertz, Nick Woltemade, and Jonathan Tah all failed to convert their attempts, leading to a shocking defeat against Paraguay.

This loss signifies a departure from the traditional German footballing identity, often characterized by resilience and effectiveness in knockout stages. The team has now failed to reach the last 16 for the third consecutive World Cup, with their last knockout victory dating back to the 2014 final.

Julian Nagelsmann, the current manager, faces scrutiny as his tenure has seen Germany perform well initially but falter in crucial matches. Despite impressive wins against Scotland and Curacao, their performances against tougher opponents raised questions about their strategy and execution.

• Key issues included:
  • Underwhelming performances from key players like Leroy Sane, who lost possession repeatedly against Paraguay.
  • Controversial decisions, such as starting Sane over Jamal Musiala, who was benched despite his potential.
  • The return of veteran goalkeeper Manuel Neuer, who appeared out of form.

Germany's tactical approach, influenced by Pep Guardiola, has been criticized for lacking the traditional German strengths of presence and tenacity. The absence of a standout striker, like Miroslav Klose, further complicates their situation.

As the football landscape evolves, Germany grapples with a new identity, struggling to cope with rising global competition. The shock of their early exit has left players like Havertz reflecting on the unexpected nature of their defeat, highlighting the shift in expectations for a once-dominant footballing nation.