Winners
Cavan Sullivan
The buzz around Sullivan’s potential debut was palpable, and the 17-year-old delivered, particularly against Mexico. His energetic play and willingness to take risks captured the attention of fans, offering a refreshing perspective after the USMNT's World Cup exit. While caution remains, many are starting to believe in his potential.

Sebastian Berhalter
Berhalter showcased his talent as a sub at the World Cup and proved effective in a start against Mexico. His ability to break defensive lines and deliver precise dead-ball services highlighted his value to the team, a significant improvement over previous corner kick struggles.

Diego Kochen
In his debut, Kochen displayed impressive composure, helping the team to a 3-0 victory over Mexico. His command in goal, coupled with a strong background from Barcelona, raises questions about whether he is the future of US goalkeeping.

Julian Hall
Unlike typical strikers, Hall’s exceptional spatial awareness and improving finishing skills make him a standout. As he continues to start for New York, he shows promise as a worthy apprentice to first-choice striker Folarin Balogun.

Losers
Christian Pulisic
Pulisic's absence from Mauricio Pochettino’s roster raised eyebrows, especially given his recent recovery from injury. Pochettino avoided discussing Pulisic directly, focusing instead on younger players and their commitment to the team.

Pochettino Non-Believers
Critics of Pochettino’s return may find it hard to argue against his choices this window. The blend of youth and experience was effective, and players praised his leadership and the infectious energy he cultivated.

Sergiño Dest
Dest struggled during the World Cup, failing to provide width or defend effectively. Pochettino’s attempt to reposition him on the wing faces competition from Sullivan and others, complicating his role moving forward.