Adding J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants roster has sparked mixed reactions, but on CBS Sports' "Set Hut," Super Bowl champion Russell Wilson and Pro Bowler Kyle Long discussed the potential benefits of this controversial trade with the Minnesota Vikings. The Giants made this move following a season-ending knee injury to starting quarterback Jaxson Dart, which required surgery.

Wilson described the trade as "interesting," suggesting it could be a "great" opportunity for McCarthy to revitalize his career. While the starting position will eventually return to Dart, McCarthy has the chance to learn from veteran starter Jameis Winston. Wilson emphasized the importance of mentorship, noting that he and Winston were teammates on the 2025 Giants.

Long stressed the need for clear communication from the team to McCarthy, stating that Winston is the current starter and Dart will reclaim his role when healthy. He expressed confidence that Winston would provide valuable guidance to McCarthy during this transition.

In college, McCarthy secured a title under coach Jim Harbaugh at Michigan. Wilson also highlighted the strategic advantage for coach John Harbaugh, stating that having a competitive high draft pick as a backup is beneficial.

McCarthy's journey has been tumultuous; his rookie season was cut short by a knee injury, and despite being named starter in Minnesota in 2025, he faced multiple setbacks including a high ankle sprain, concussion, and hand injury, leading to a 6-4 record with a 57.6% completion rate, 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions.

Now, with injuries reshaping the quarterback room in New York, Long concluded, "They need him, and he needs them, so I think it's a good situation for him."