The first Test match in Durban saw Australia grappling with a disastrous start, largely due to the controversial selection of Nic Maddinson, who fell for a 33-ball duck, leaving the team at a precarious 187 for 6 when play was halted by bad light. Maddinson's dismal performance raised eyebrows, as he struggled against Wiaan Mulder and seemed out of his depth, having not played first-class cricket since March 2025.

Critics of the selection pointed to better alternatives, such as Jake Weatherald and Matt Renshaw, who were overlooked in favor of Maddinson, whose recent form had been lackluster. Following Maddinson's dismissal, Travis Head also fell early, putting Australia further in jeopardy.

However, the partnership of Steve Smith and Marnus Labuschagne provided a glimmer of hope, as they added 60 runs before the lunch break. Smith showcased aggression against Keshav Maharaj, hitting two sixes, but both fell victim to the South African bowlers shortly after.

At 124 for 6, disaster loomed until Renshaw, batting unexpectedly in the middle order, steadied the ship alongside Pat Cummins. Their partnership of 63 runs brought some stability to Australia's innings, with Renshaw scoring 46 by the end of the day.

As the match heads into day two, Australia must rally around Renshaw to capitalize on their remaining time and regain control of the game, addressing broader issues with their batting lineup that have plagued them in recent times.