Alan Shearer has urged Manchester United to consider Fabian Hürzeler as a viable candidate to replace Michael Carrick if the club decides to make a managerial change. Carrick is under substantial pressure following a dismal start to the season, with only two victories from their opening 10 matches across all competitions.

Despite the board backing Carrick for the moment, a continuation of poor results could prompt INEOS to reassess their position. In stark contrast, Hürzeler has led Brighton to a remarkable third place in the Premier League, showcasing an impressive and tactically flexible team.

If Carrick is relieved of his duties, Hürzeler would be a good replacement, but it’s a very different model at Brighton.” He also mentioned Eddie Howe and Antonio Conte as potential alternatives while acknowledging the inevitable speculation surrounding United’s managerial situation.

Hürzeler’s credentials have been bolstered following Brighton's emphatic 5-0 victory over Crystal Palace, marking a total of 23 goals in seven league matches. Brighton chairman Tony Bloom praised Hürzeler for delivering consistent on-pitch performances" and developing a "clear playing identity."

Under Hürzeler, Brighton has demonstrated resilience, intensity, and control—qualities currently lacking at United. His aggressive pressing and tactical flexibility align with the long-term vision that INEOS desires. However, Shearer cautioned that managing at Old Trafford presents unique challenges, including recruitment issues and immense external pressure.

As of now, Carrick retains his position, but if results do not improve swiftly, Hürzeler’s name is likely to remain in the conversation.